Canadian Crime Writers 2014 Best Crime Novel - Winner. The Jury writes: Sean Haldane's THE DEVIL's MAKING is the standout choice for the 2014 Arthur Ellis Best Novel award. It is a story about a young English policeman--a man of the 'new science' influenced by Charles Darwin--who investigates a grisly murder in colonial Victoria, B.C., in 1869. Chad Hobbes is a highly articulate and likeable character, an innocent whose skills and very identity are challenged by this case. Skillful diction; accurate historical detail; a compelling plot that fuses premonitions of evil with lyrical descriptions of the landscape; and a fine balance of action, exposition and fact are the hallmarks of this story about secrets and lies. Haldane brings a modern sensibility to this first-person narrative about Hobbes's pursuit of the murderer. The dead man was a doctor who used the new, controversial theories of phrenology and mesmerism to treat his patients. Haldane's sympathetic yet unromantic portrayal of the First Nations Tsimshian people and of the tensions within a pioneer society is remarkable. The dialogue reveals character in subtle ways, the Victorian tone never descending into hokum or artificiality. The characters' actions are clearly motivated; clues well placed; revelations leading to the climax never forced or implausible. THE DEVIL'S MAKING's polished narrative involves intriguing characters, and its themes of racial prejudice, self-doubt, notions of civilization and love never slow its pace or overwhelm its story. It is a wonderful read, the best of 2013.